Bit Computers Commodore 64

Sid Meier’s Pirates : Commodore 64 Review

Ooofffff!!!! This was a very tough one as there are a heap of truly outstanding games for the C64 of which any of them could have grabbed the coveted top slot. But for us, and me in particular, this was a game that had me enthralled, and being a Speccy owner, I had withdrawals playing this for endless hours around a friends house when I was younger. I constantly asked and enquired to my local computer shop when this was going to be released for the Spectrum as well as writing a letter to MicroProse to ask them (luckily I never posted it). Such was my addiction to this game.

When MicroProse makes a simulation, they don’t do things halfway. So when they released Pirates!—complete with an 88-page manual and a historically accurate map of the Spanish Main—you could be sure this was as close to real piracy as you could get without actually stepping onto a ship.

There are two ways to approach the game: you can dive right in, hoist your sails, and learn as you go, or you can read the manual from cover to cover before even touching the joystick. But this isn’t your standard instruction booklet—it’s practically a historical compendium. Alongside details on how to play, it’s packed with notes on the politics, geography, and naval tactics of the 17th century, all framed as the colorful “Memoirs of Capt’n Sydney.” You’ll learn more from one of Sydney’s tales than from weeks at sea.

The goal of Pirates! is to live the life of a 17th-century sea rogue. You’ll need a ship and a loyal crew, then set sail to raid, trade, plunder, and hunt for treasure. But don’t think you can just go around looting every vessel in sight—this is a simulation, not a free-for-all. Every action has consequences, and a good captain must always weigh his choices carefully.

I think sailing into harbour might be the call here, bit early to start brassing stuff up with canonballs
Selling some ships does conjure up quite a bit of cash.

Like any great simulation, Pirates! offers multiple ways to play. You can start as an English Buccaneer, French Adventurer, Dutch Privateer, or Spanish Renegade. Difficulty ranges from Apprentice to Swashbuckler, and you can even choose a special skill to give your captain an edge—fencing, navigation, gunnery, charm, or medicine. Beginners are advised to start with fencing.

You can also embark on one of several historical expeditions, re-creating real pirate voyages with you at the helm instead of the famous captains of old:

Hmmm, some well known sea dog is chasing us. Runaway is always a good option.
But when you have to stand your ground and fight, you stand your ground and fight.

Authenticity is Pirates!’ greatest strength. Gameplay is a mix of strategy, adventure, and arcade action, with every choice made by selecting options from a cutlass-shaped cursor.

While in port, you can visit the governor to hear political news or gain rewards for attacking enemy nations. Loyal service might even earn you land and titles. The tavern is where you’ll recruit new crew members, pick up rumors, or divide your plunder to start a new voyage. You can also consult your ship’s log, check morale, or chart your position with a sun sight.

Enguarde!!!!! Swashbuckling action on the decks of a pirate ship.
About to nick Count Clinton’s mrs, he won’t be too happy I’m sure. Just don’t show your too keen. Propose marriage….. damn!!!!

Of course, piracy is about more than taverns and trade. You’ll find plenty of action on both land and sea. Sea battles begin with a sighting of sails on the horizon—your lookout will tell you what kind of ship it is and what flag she flies. Once you close in, tactics are everything. Maneuver your vessel, fire broadsides, and when ready, board the enemy ship to engage in a duel with the opposing captain.

You can choose from several swords—rapier, longsword, or cutlass—each with its own strengths. Swordplay uses joystick motions to perform attack and defense combinations. Crew morale depends heavily on your performance in combat; if you fight bravely, your men will rally, even when outnumbered. A crew in “panic” will surrender quickly, but one that’s “wild!” with morale can overcome the odds.

Piracy isn’t limited to open waters either. You can raid towns and forts from land or sea. On land, you’ll command groups of musketeers, using forests for cover and driving the enemy into retreat before storming the fort’s walls. From the sea, you’ll have to dodge cannon fire, land your men strategically, and lead the final swordfight yourself.

We are truly screwed here. Maybe we should have chirpsed those birds a bit more and got married.
Another reason to feel deflated, our boat has more holes than a……… pirate ship with lots of holes……..

Describing Pirates! barely does it justice. It’s a vast and complex experience that blends historical simulation, adventure, and strategy seamlessly. Every element—from the political alliances to the dueling mechanics—adds to a deep and immersive world.

In terms of realism, historical accuracy, and sheer entertainment, Pirates! stands head and shoulders above every other so-called “swashbuckling simulation.” It’s rich, atmospheric, and endlessly replayable. Anyone looking to capture the thrill of life on the Spanish Main will find Pirates! an absolute treasure.

MicroProse didn’t just make a game—they crafted an experience. And if any other studio had planned at the time to jump aboard the pirate craze, they would have had to sail a very long way to catch up.

Top slot for us and well deserved.

BREAKDOWN:

GRAPHICS: 65%
MUSIC/SFX: 60%
PLAYABLITY: 99%
OVERALL: 98%

Platform: Commodore 64
Genre: Strategy – General
Developer/ Publisher: MicroProse
Release: 1987
Franchise: Sid Meier’s

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *