Retro TV

Scrooged : Retro TV Movie Review

“Scrooged” emerges as an unsettling and disquieting film, intended as a comedy but laden with little humor. The predominant emotions conveyed throughout the movie are pain and anger, leaving the entire production yearning for visits from the ghosts of Christmas.

Bill Murray takes on the role of Frank Cross, a tormented TV network president approaching the Christmas season with a foul mood. Seemingly disconnected from those who care for him, he delights in criticizing and humiliating colleagues, leading a lonely existence in his high-rise office, immersed in TV and alcohol. His promotional tactics involve scaring viewers into watching, and his upcoming live Christmas Eve performance of “Scrooge” becomes a chaotic endeavor as he attempts to wreck both the show and his own life.

Cross is portrayed as a thoroughly miserable character, and Murray’s performance lacks the lightness and good cheer typical of his roles. While Murray often embodies gruffness in a playful manner, this time, the humor seems absent.

Murray’s ill humor permeates scenes, creating an undertow that alters the chemistry between characters. His shouts lack the self-mocking exaggeration that usually signals humor, leaving the audience unsure whether to laugh. The other actors, too, appear genuinely affected by his on-screen outbursts.

As the narrative unfolds, Cross undergoes his own version of the transformative events from Charles Dickens’ “A Christmas Carol.” Visited by the ghosts of Christmas past, present, and future, he confronts the misery he has created for himself and others. His secretary, Grace Cooley (Alfre Woodard), serves as the Bob Cratchit character in his story, with her son playing the role of a silent Tiny Tim. A seemingly thoughtless Christmas gift from Cross takes on a new perspective when he witnesses the profound happiness missing from his own life during a ghostly visit to Cooley’s household.

Meanwhile, professional challenges emerge for Cross as the network’s CEO (Robert Mitchum) loses confidence in him, bringing in an assertive outsider (John Glover) to assist. Cross fears for his job, especially with the CEO’s eccentric behavior. The fear of job loss and the lessons from the Christmas ghosts lead to a moral transformation for Cross. In the final scenes, the repentant TV executive interrupts the live production of “Scrooge” to express his change of heart.

This sequence stands out as the strangest in the film. While the words are spoken, the emotional depth is lacking. Murray takes center stage, delivering a speech about the spirit of Christmas, but it falls short of inspiration and humor. Instead, it feels desperate and extends uncomfortably. Murray’s on-screen breakdown becomes apparent.

In a climactic moment, he calls for a miracle, and his secretary’s son is brought forward to demonstrate his newfound ability to speak. The entire cast and crew join Murray to sing about Christmas cheer, creating a forced and depressing atmosphere.

What went wrong in this scene? The chemistry may have been off from the beginning, or the material itself could be challenging. One issue is Murray’s frequent insertion of one-liners that disrupt the flow of the story, creating a sense that he is distancing himself from the film at those moments. For a story like this to work, it needs to believe in itself.

Continuously criticizing “A Christmas Carol” throughout and then expecting the audience to believe in the good cheer at the end poses a challenge. In his studies of Dickens for this role, Murray appears to have focused only on “Bah! Humbug!”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *