
Should I reveal that “Elf” features Will Ferrell as Buddy, a human who believes he’s an elf, and Ed Asner as Santa Claus, would your immediate reaction be a burning desire to watch this film? I confess, the prospect did not captivate me. I anticipated clumsiness, stupidity, and predictability akin to “The Santa Clause 2” or “How the Grinch Stole Christmas.” I envisioned tacky special effects stumbling through the remnants of holiday cheer, forcing upon us a saccharine romance involving the only woman in America oblivious to the fact that a man who believes he’s an elf is inherently eccentric.
That was my initial impression. However, it took a mere 10 seconds of witnessing Will Ferrell don the elf costume for me to realize how mistaken I was. “Elf” defies expectations, standing out as a rare Christmas comedy endowed with heart, intelligence, and a wicked sense of humor. It effortlessly charms its way into your heart. Even the unconventional casting choices prove spot-on: James Caan as the elf’s biological father? Yes! Bob Newhart as his adoptive elf father? Yes! Mary Steenburgen as Caan’s wife, embracing an adult son into her family? Yes! Zooey Deschanel as the department store girl enchanted by his elfin charm? Yes! Faizon Love as Santa’s elf manager? Does it get any better? Yes, it does. Peter Dinklage, the dwarf in “The Station Agent,” has a brief but sublime scene getting straight to the essence of elfhood.
Directed by Jon Favreau and written by David Berenbaum, “Elf” kicks off with a poignant misunderstanding on a Christmas long ago. A human orphan inadvertently stows away in Santa Claus’s sack during his rounds, ending up at the North Pole. Raised as an elf by Papa Elf (Newhart), he becomes acutely aware of being four feet taller than his fellow elves. Eventually, he sets off to New York City to find his birth father, Walter (Caan), a toughened publisher whose heart doesn’t immediately thaw at the sight of a 6-foot man in a green tunic and yellow stretch tights claiming to be his son. However, when Buddy mentions Walter’s long-lost girlfriend, a distant look appears in the old man’s eyes, and soon Buddy is welcomed into their home by Steenburgen, the only actress capable of making us believe she genuinely embraces her husband’s elfish, out-of-wedlock son.
The plot follows a familiar trajectory involving a crisis at Walter’s publishing company and the need for a best-selling children’s book. Yet, “Elf” weaves in sweet subplots involving Buddy’s new little brother Michael (Daniel Tay) and Buddy’s endearing yet awkward romance with the department store girl (Deschanel). Add heart-warming unfinished business at the North Pole, and you have a holiday film that transcends expectations.
Naturally, there’s a pivotal moment involving Buddy’s confrontation with the department store Santa Claus, a shrewd elf who Buddy promptly identifies as a fraud. “You sit on a throne of lies!” he boldly declares to this counterfeit Santa.
In this jaded world, even Santa Claus is grappling with a crisis of belief, leading to an energy shortage this year. Santa’s sleigh relies on faith, and if there’s a shortage of believers, the sleigh can’t take flight. This predicament sets the stage for one of those classic scenes where a flying contraption—in this peculiar case, the very sleigh under discussion—struggles to achieve takeoff velocity. It becomes a nerve-wracking scenario; after all, it would be catastrophic if Santa were to plummet in flames. Let’s hope Buddy can work his charm and persuade enough people to believe. It sounds simple enough, considering he convinced me that this was a great movie—a genuine miracle on 34th Street right there.





